Brief 02 // Administrative Tax Research
The Gap Between Survey Estimates and Tax Filings in U.S. Independent Work
Over the past decade, economists studying independent contracting and alternative work arrangements in the United States have debated whether non-traditional labor has expanded rapidly or remained relatively stable. The debate illustrates how measurement design shapes public understanding of supplemental income, with two landmark research streams—one survey-based and one built on administrative tax filings—highlighting both genuine structural growth and important statistical caveats.
In a widely cited 2019 study published in the ILR Review, economists Lawrence F. Katz and Alan B. Krueger fielded the RAND-Princeton Contingent Worker Survey in late 2015 and compared the results with the Bureau of Labor Statistics Contingent Worker Supplement from 2005. Their initial comparison suggested a sharp rise in the share of U.S. workers engaged in alternative work arrangements—including independent contractors, on-call workers, and contract-firm employees—from roughly 10.7 percent in 2005 to 15.8 percent in 2015.
However, when the Bureau of Labor Statistics released its own updated Contingent Worker Supplement in 2017, the federal survey showed a slight decline rather than an increase in alternative work as a primary job. In a subsequent methodological reassessment, Katz and Krueger examined this discrepancy directly. They concluded that differences in survey timing—specifically higher unemployment conditions in 2015 compared with 2017—along with subtle variations in questionnaire wording and interview mode accounted for a meaningful portion of the divergence between the two datasets.
What IRS Administrative Records Reveal
To bypass the limitations of small-sample surveys, a team of economists affiliated with the U.S. Treasury and the Internal Revenue Service—Brett Collins, Andrew Garin, Emilie Jackson, Dmitri Koustas, and Mark Payne—examined the full population of U.S. federal tax filings from 2000 through 2016. By tracking Form 1099-MISC, Form 1099-K, and Schedule C filings across millions of anonymized returns, the authors documented a steady upward trend in the share of the U.S. workforce receiving at least some independent-contractor income.
Crucially, Collins, Garin, Jackson, Koustas, and Payne found that the majority of the post-2013 growth in 1099 filings was concentrated among individuals earning relatively modest supplemental amounts via online labor platforms, rather than full-time workers abandoning traditional W-2 employment. For most filers in this expanding segment, independent work functioned as an intermittent secondary stream alongside conventional wages.
Limits of Tax-Record Analysis
While administrative tax data resolves recall error and sample-size noise, labor economists note significant methodological constraints in tax-based studies as well. First, information returns such as Form 1099-K report gross payment volume before platform commissions, processing fees, equipment costs, or mileage deductions, meaning gross figures overstate actual disposable income. Second, statutory reporting thresholds have shifted over time, creating artificial spikes or drops in recorded filers whenever federal rules change. Third, tax filings record annual totals rather than weekly hours, making it impossible to calculate exact hourly net compensation from tax forms alone.
Taken together, the exchange between Katz and Krueger's survey work and the Treasury-IRS research by Collins and coauthors underscores a foundational principle in labor economics: supplemental contracting in the United States is real and widespread, yet its exact magnitude depends on whether analysts measure primary jobs, annual secondary filings, or net after-expense earnings.